1

Topic: Copy progress?

I'm guessing that I'm probably not the first person to have mentioned this, but it would be Nice, if there was something shown (like fer instance a progress bar) during a partition copy operation which would indicate either the amount completed or else, better still, an estimated time to completion for the copy.

2

Re: Copy progress?

What version of GParted are you using?

The newer versions of GParted (most recent is 0.18.0) include a copy progress bar and a time estimate for the copy to complete.  See Sample Applying Pending Operations.

3

Re: Copy progress?

Ummm... I'm now using the latest, gparted-live-0.18.0-2-amd64.iso.

Yes, there is a kind of a "progress bar" showing the number of "Completed Operations".  But I am just simply copying one rather large partition from one drive to another, and it is only showing me "0 of 1 operations completed".  It is not showing me how much of the current (large and time consuming) copy operation has been completed so far.

Am I doing something wrong?

P.S.  The example screen shot you pointed me at seems to show a partition move operation... not an actual partition copy operation.

It is certainly a Good Thing[tm] if there is now a progress bar for move operations.  Are there plans to implement the same also for copy operations someday?

4

Re: Copy progress?

I just tried copying a partition containing a btrfs file system and I see both the the copy progress bar and the completed operations progress bar.

What type of file system are you copying?

5

Re: Copy progress?

gedakc wrote:

I just tried copying a partition containing a btrfs file system and I see both the the copy progress bar and the completed operations progress bar.

What type of file system are you copying?

NTFS

6 (edited by gedakc 2014-05-13 18:11:19)

Re: Copy progress?

To copy ntfs file systems, GParted uses the ntfsclone command.

You might investigate the following in-progress bug report and help by testing the latest patches:

Bug 467925 - gparted: add progress bar during operation

EDIT:  I'm fairly certain that progress bars were implemented for copying ntfs partitions.  However, when I create an NTFS partition and test a copy, the operation runs quickly and there is not enough elapsed time to see a progress bar.

You might want to open a terminal window and run "ps -ef | grep ntfsclone" to see if the ntfsclone process exists.

EDIT2:  With asynchronous execution of the commands in GParted, you can expand the details pane and watch the progress of the command while it executes.

7

Re: Copy progress?

gedakc wrote:

EDIT:  I'm fairly certain that progress bars were implemented for copying ntfs

I can only reiterate what I saw, which was an utter absence of any such progress indication.

Are you suggesting that I should clean my glasses?

However, when I create an NTFS partition and test a copy, the operation runs quickly and there is not enough elapsed time to see a progress bar.

May I, with all respect, suggest that you try again with a larger NTFS partition and/or a slower source or target drive?

8 (edited by gedakc 2014-05-14 17:25:34)

Re: Copy progress?

ronbaby wrote:
gedakc wrote:

EDIT:  I'm fairly certain that progress bars were implemented for copying ntfs

I can only reiterate what I saw, which was an utter absence of any such progress indication.

Are you suggesting that I should clean my glasses?

I'm not suggesting you clean your glasses.

In my second edit I suggested expanding the details to see the output from the command used to copy ntfs (ntfsclone).

EDIT:  We appreciate when persons, such as yourself, can dig further into an issue.  This enables us to continue work on other fronts at the same time.  That is why I also mentioned the bug report that includes improvements to progress reporting.

9

Re: Copy progress?

gedakc wrote:

In my second edit I suggested expanding the details to see the output from the command used to copy ntfs (ntfsclone).

EDIT:  We appreciate when persons, such as yourself, can dig further into an issue.  This enables us to continue work on other fronts at the same time.  That is why I also mentioned the bug report that includes improvements to progress reporting.

If I can be of help, then I feel an obligation to do so.  However before i start performing further analysis, tests, experiments, and what not, I feel that it would be appropriate if first we can find at least one person who can replicate the issue/problem that I've already found and reported.  If that's not possible... if nobody in the universe can reproduce what I believe I saw, then we can all save ourselves a lot of time and bother and just assume that yes, I actually do need to clean my glasses.

Would it be possible for you or someone else working on Gparted to try... with the same official release that I noted earlier in this thread (0.18.2)... to perform a copy of a sizable NTFS partition from one disk to another, where at least one of the two is not, um, ultra fast (such as an SSD)?

10

Re: Copy progress?

It is certainly possible, but is low on my list as I am preparing for another release.  The natural place where this can be picked up is in the progress bar bug report mentioned earlier in this thread.